The Truth About Carbohydrates: Why Some Thrive While Others Struggle
When it comes to diet and nutrition, carbohydrates have been one of the most debated topics over the last couple of decades. Once the foundation of the now-discredited food pyramid, carbs are now viewed with suspicion in certain dietary trends (like paleo and primal) or outright avoided in others (such as the carnivore diet).
But here’s the paradox: while some people thrive on a high-carb diet, others seem to gain weight just by being near a plate of pasta. So, what’s the deal? Why do carbs affect people so differently?
Let’s dive into what influences carbohydrate tolerance and clear up some common misconceptions about this misunderstood macronutrient.
Carbs Aren’t the Villain (and They’re Not Making You Fat)
Despite what keto or paleo advocates might claim, carbohydrates are the body’s primary energy source, especially during physically demanding activities like resistance training, interval training, or circuit training. Your body is designed to run on glucose—a carbohydrate-derived fuel.
Carbs are also affordable, widely available, and have played a critical role in human evolution. Even during periods of rest or low-intensity activities, the body relies partially on carbohydrates for energy.
However, not all carbs are created equal. Nutrient-dense sources like fruits, vegetables, and whole grains differ significantly from ultra-processed carbs like candy, chips, or soda. The former provide fiber, vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants, while the latter are often just empty calories that spike blood sugar and insulin levels without offering much nutritional value.
That said, weight gain isn’t caused by carbs alone—it’s about overall calorie intake. You could theoretically lose weight eating processed foods like doughnuts or chips, as long as you maintain a calorie deficit. The problem is, ultra-processed foods are typically high in calories, low in fiber and protein (key nutrients for satiety), and easy to overconsume.
To sum it up: carbs alone aren’t responsible for weight gain. With the right approach, you can enjoy carbohydrates while losing weight, building muscle, and supporting your overall health.
Why Some People Tolerate Carbs Better
Several factors influence how individuals process carbohydrates, including:
1. Genetics
Genetics significantly affect how your body metabolizes carbs. Some people inherit genes that allow them to handle carbohydrates efficiently, avoiding blood sugar spikes and crashes.
2. Insulin Sensitivity
Insulin plays a vital role in blood sugar regulation and nutrient storage. Individuals with high insulin sensitivity can process carbs more effectively, using glucose for energy or storage without negative effects. Those with poor insulin sensitivity or insulin resistance may struggle with higher-carb diets.
3. Activity Level
Carbs are the preferred energy source during physical activity. Active individuals—particularly those engaging in high-intensity exercise—require more carbs to fuel their workouts and replenish glycogen stores. On the other hand, sedentary people may need fewer carbs since their muscles demand less energy.
4. Gut Microbiome
Your gut bacteria play a critical role in digesting food, including carbohydrates. A healthy, diverse microbiome improves carbohydrate digestion, while insufficient fiber intake can harm gut health. Natural fiber-rich carb sources like fruits, veggies, whole grains, and legumes support gut bacteria, stabilizing energy levels and hunger.
5. Age
As we age, our metabolism slows, and hormone levels change, which can impact how the body processes carbs. Maintaining a healthy body composition and staying active can help mitigate these effects and preserve insulin sensitivity.
6. Dietary Choices
The quality of your carb intake matters. Natural, fiber-rich carbs promote stable energy levels and satiety, while ultra-processed carbs can lead to overeating. Pairing carbs with protein and healthy fats also slows digestion, helping to manage blood sugar levels and hunger.
7. Personal Preference
Some people naturally enjoy higher-carb diets, while others feel better eating more protein and fat. Personal habits and food preferences also play a role—those who gravitate toward high-carb junk foods may benefit from moderating their intake to avoid overconsuming calories.
Carbs Are Not the Enemy
Carbohydrates are the body’s go-to energy source, especially during exercise. Factors like genetics, activity level, diet quality, age, and personal preference all contribute to how well your body handles carbs.
Understanding these factors can help you design a diet that aligns with your fitness and health goals. And remember: a balanced diet, paired with regular physical activity, allows most people to enjoy carbs without fear.
Ready to Take Control of Your Fitness?
At ActivU Fitness, we bring personal training directly to you. No more commuting, crowded gyms, or wondering where to start. Our trainers come fully prepared to deliver personalized workouts at your home or preferred location, designed to fit your unique goals, schedule, and fitness level.
Whether you’re looking to lose weight, gain muscle, or boost overall wellness, our mobile personal training service makes fitness convenient, accessible, and effective. Let us take the stress out of your health journey so you can focus on achieving sustainable results.
Click here to schedule your first session with ActivU Fitness and start transforming your life today!
References
1. National Research Council (US) Committee on Diet and Health. Diet and Health: Implications for Reducing Chronic Disease Risk. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 1989. Carbohydrates
2. Hardy, K., Brand-Miller, J., Brown, K. D., Thomas, M. G., & Copeland, L. (2015). The Importance of Dietary Carbohydrate in Human Evolution. The Quarterly Review of Biology, 90(3), 251–268. DOI
Comments